Ferrari 488 vs McLaren 650S Hire: Two Twin-Turbo V8 Rivals Compared

The 488 and the 650S were rivals when they were new and they still are. Each puts a twin-turbocharged V8 in the middle of the car, drives the rear wheels and reaches 100km/h in three seconds. The McLaren answers with a carbon tub and doors that rise towards the sky; the Ferrari answers with its badge, its cabin and its voice. The McLaren is ours and bookable today, the 488 is sourced for your dates, and this page sets out how to choose.

★★★★★ Rated 5.0 from 1,431 reviews across Drive Tribe

The Short Answer

These two were built in the same years to almost the same recipe, so the choice comes down to
temperament rather than numbers. Book the McLaren 650S if you want the lighter, sharper, more
technical car, the doors that open upwards, and a booking you can make now: it is our own car,
bookable today from $2,600 a day. Wait for the Ferrari 488 if the badge, the richer cabin and the
sound matter more to you than the last degree of precision, or if you want the Spider with its
folding hard top. The 488 is confirmed by request from $2,500 a day, which means we source a car
for your dates and send you its details and the full price before any payment.

One thing applies to both. Each pushes a large dose of turbocharged torque through its rear tyres alone, and each rewards a driver with real experience of powerful cars. Our 488 review describes the Ferrari as a car for people who have done this before, and that description fits the McLaren every bit as well. If the forecast is wet or the driver is newer to this class, the Huracan is the
better call, for reasons set out near the end of this page.

Specifications, Car Against Car

The 488 figures are Ferrari's published numbers for the GTB coupe; the Spider shares its engine and
power under a folding hard top. The McLaren column matches our own car. Ferrari quotes 760Nm of
torque for the 488, and that figure explains much of its character. On acceleration the table
calls it a draw, and on the road the two are close enough that the difference in feel matters far
more than the difference in output.

Where They Actually Differ

Two ways to deliver turbocharged thrust

Ferrari manages the 488's torque so that it builds as you move up through the gears, which
makes the car feel strong and even rather than sudden. Press the throttle at modest revs and the
response is prompt, and the shove grows in proportion to your foot. It is a very fast car that
behaves in a measured, predictable way, and that makes it easy to drive smoothly at the kind of
pace a Sydney road allows.

The McLaren feels more like a machine built with one purpose. At low revs there is a small
gathering of breath before the turbochargers are fully awake, and then a harder, more urgent rush
through the middle of the range. Drivers who like a car with an edge to it tend to prefer that;
drivers who want every input answered in exactly the same way tend to prefer the Ferrari. Neither
approach is slow, and neither is difficult once you have spent twenty minutes with it.

Carbon tub against aluminium

The McLaren is built around a single carbon fibre tub, which is why it feels so taut and so
light on its feet. Every input goes straight into the structure with nothing soft in between, and
the steering is full of information about the surface underneath. Its suspension links the
dampers hydraulically instead of relying on conventional anti-roll bars, and the result is a car
that rides broken tarmac with surprising composure for something so stiff. Bells Line of Road, with its patched and changing surface, is exactly where that pairing shows what the 650S is for.

The 488 uses an aluminium chassis and feels a little more substantial, and a little more like a
very fast grand tourer. Its steering is quick and light, and the car changes direction eagerly,
but it wraps the driver in slightly more insulation. The McLaren tells you everything; the Ferrari
tells you what you need. If you want a road car that feels closest to something built for a circuit, take the 650S. If you want a supercar that is easier to relax in, the 488 will suit
you better.

The doors, and getting in and out

The McLaren's dihedral doors are the part everyone photographs. They swing upwards and slightly
outwards, and at a venue or a set of lights they draw a crowd within seconds. They are also more
practical than they look, because they need less space at the side of the car than a long
conventional door. What catches people out is the sill: the carbon tub leaves a wide step between
you and the seat, so the graceful way in is to sit on the edge first and then bring your legs
across. There is no ordinary handle either, and we show you the release at the handover.

The 488 has conventional doors and a narrower, lower sill, which makes it the easier car to get
in and out of in a hurry, in formal clothes or in a tight space. It lacks the moment of theatre
when the doors go up, but it gets people in and out with less fuss.

The badge and the reaction it gets

Almost everyone recognises a Ferrari. The prancing horse means something to people who have
never read a car magazine, and a red 488 parked outside a harbourside restaurant gets the reaction
you would expect. A McLaren is recognised most readily by people who follow cars, and they tend to
approach it with more questions and more knowledge. Children point at the doors. Enthusiasts ask
about the carbon tub.

Which reaction you want is a fair question to ask yourself. For a milestone birthday or an
arrival where the badge has to mean something to every guest, the Ferrari has the edge. For a
day built around the driving, where the audience that matters is you, the McLaren's quieter
reputation is no loss at all.

Cabins, controls and the sound

The 488's cabin is the more luxurious of the two. Leather covers most of what you touch, the
steering wheel carries the manettino, the starter and the indicators, and the whole space feels
built for an occasion. The McLaren's cabin is plainer and more focused: a thin-rimmed wheel with
almost nothing on it, a small portrait screen in the centre, and drive modes set on a panel
between the seats. Both are two-seaters with luggage space under the front bonnet for soft bags
only.

Neither engine sings the way the naturally aspirated 458 did, and that comparison has its own
page in the 458 and 488 comparison. Between these two,
the Ferrari has the more tuneful voice, a deep, hard V8 note that builds into a roar. The McLaren
sounds more industrial, with more turbocharger noise audible from the driver's seat. Some drivers
love that sense of machinery at work. Anyone hiring a supercar mainly for its sound will
generally be happier in the Ferrari.

Rear tyres, rain and respect

Both cars put all their effort through the rear tyres, and both produce more than enough torque
to overwhelm those tyres on a damp road if the driver is careless. The traction systems in each
are excellent. Keep them on, keep the Ferrari's manettino in sport as its review advises, and
drive smoothly, and either car is manageable. It still takes concentration, though, and that is
the point at which the all-wheel-drive Huracan
becomes the more sensible booking for a wet weekend or a less experienced driver.

What Makes the McLaren Simpler to Book

The 650S is our own car. We know how it has been maintained and when it is free, we show you its nose lift when you collect it, and its bond, excess and kilometre allowance are printed on the booking for you to read first. If your dates are free, the booking is finished in minutes.

The 488 is sourced for you. We track down a car in good order, check whether it is a GTB or a Spider and whether its nose can be raised, and then write to you with the details and the price. All of that needs a little time, and a very late request can simply run out of it. A request sent several weeks ahead has
a far better chance than one sent on a Wednesday for the coming Saturday. When a 488 cannot be
found for your dates, the McLaren is the first alternative we offer.

When the 488 Is Worth Waiting For

When the badge is part of the reason. Some occasions call for a Ferrari
specifically, and no other maker, however quick, fills that role. If the day involves a guest list,
a photographer or a parent who has always wanted to ride in one, the 488 does a job the McLaren
cannot.

When you want the Spider. The 488 Spider stows its roof in the bodywork behind the cabin, and with it gone far more of the V8 reaches your ears. For a warm evening on the coast, an open roof is
a real reason to choose the Ferrari and ask early.

When you want a calmer companion for a long day. Neither car tolerates carelessness, yet the Ferrari's even delivery and gentler edges make a long day at the wheel easier to sustain. Drivers who find the McLaren's intensity tiring after a few hours often feel more
at home in the Ferrari.

When the rate matters. The 488 is offered below the McLaren's daily rate.
Over a longer hire, and with flexible dates, that difference can make the Ferrari the more
economical way to drive a twin-turbo mid-engined car.

Which One to Book

Book the McLaren if the drive is the point, if you want the sharpest car of the two, if the
doors appeal to you, or if the dates are close and you need certainty. It is ready to book on its
review page.

Book the 488 if the Ferrari name, the cabin or the sound matter more than the last degree of
sharpness, if you want the Spider, or if the booking is for an occasion rather than a road.
Its own review page covers the GTB and the Spider in full.
Whichever you choose, send the dates early and tell us the plan for the day, and we will say
honestly which of the two we would take.